Shostakovich and Khrapchenko: On the Problem of “The Artist and Power”
Abstract
The article is devoted to the history of the relationship between Dmitry Shostakovich and Mikhail Khrapchenko, Chairman of the All-Union Committee for Arts Affairs (VKDI) under the Council of People’s Commissars of the Soviet Union (1939–1948). This department was created in 1936 under the leadership of Platon Kerzhentsev. For Shostakovich, the initial period of interaction with VKDI turned out to be quite dramatic. The first major action of the VKDI was the publication of the article Muddle Instead of Music (Pravda, 28 January 1936), directed against Shostakovich’s opera Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk; this was shortly followed by another entitled Ballet Falsehood (Pravda, 6 February 1936) that made accusations against the ballet The Limpid Stream. However, the appointment of Khrapchenko to the post of chairman of the VKDI in 1939 radically changed the position of Shostakovich, whose support by the new head of the department would benefit him greatly in the years to come. The article reconstructs the entire period of communication between Shostakovich and Khrapchenko based on archival documents, memoirs, letters and periodical press materials. The composer repeatedly turned to Khrapchenko for help and invariably received it in both creative and everyday matters. In 1948, Khrapchenko, like many other artists, became a victim of the anti-formalist campaign. On Stalin’s orders, an audit was conducted of the financial costs of preparing the opera The Great Friendship by Vano Muradeli. Having been designated as responsible for the failure of the opera, Khrapchenko subsequently spent several years paying a large fine to the state. At the conference of Soviet music figures, which took place at the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Bolsheviks) from 11–13 January 1948 under the chairmanship of Andrei Zhdanov, many of those whom Khrapchenko had supported during his many years of work at the VKDI spoke out against him. The only one who spoke out in defence of Khrapchenko was Shostakovich. Until the end of his life, the composer maintained communication with Khrapchenko, who again held high positions in the 1960s and always responded to the composer’s requests when he could.
Keywords: Dmitry Shostakovich, Michail Khrapchenko, Joseph Stalin, Andrey Zhdanov, All-Union Committee for Arts Affairs, the composer and power, Soviet music, symphony, anti-formalist campaign of 1948
For citation: Naumenko, T. I. (2025). Shostakovich and Khrapchenko: On the Problem of “The Artist and Power”. Contemporary Musicology, 9(3), 12–60. https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2025-3-012-060References
Hakobyan, L. O. (2016). Shostakovich i sovetskaya vlast’. Istoriya vzaimootnoshenij [Shostakovich and the Soviet Power. History of Relations]. In L. O. Hakobyan (Ed.), D. D. Shostakovich: pro et contra. D. D. Shostakovich v otsenkakh sovremennikov, kompozitorov, publitsistov, issledovatelej, pisatelej: antologiya [D. D. Shostakovich: Pro et Contra. D. D. Shostakovich in the Assessments of Contemporaries, Composers, Publicists, Researchers, and Writers: Anthology] (pp. 7–50). RCAH [Russian Christian Academy for Humanities] Publishing House. (In Russ.).
Hakobyan, L. O. (2016). Shostakovich, Proletkul’t i RAPM [Shostakovich, Proletkul’t and RAPM]. In L. O. Hakobyan (Ed.), D. D. Shostakovich: pro et contra. D. D. Shostakovich v otsenkakh sovremennikov, kompozitorov, publitsistov, issledovatelej, pisatelej: antologiya [D. D. Shostakovich: Pro et Contra. D. D. Shostakovich in the Assessments of Contemporaries, Composers, Publicists, Researchers, and Writers: Anthology] (pp. 284–294). RCAH [Russian Christian Academy for Humanities] Publishing House. (In Russ.).
Volkov, S. (2004). Shostakovich i Stalin: khudozhnik i tsar’ [Shostakovich and Stalin: The End of a Creative Life]. Eksmo Publishing House. (In Russ.).
Shostakovich, D. D. (with Kovnatskaya, L. G.). (2006). Letters to I. I. Sollertinsky. Compozitor – Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russ.).
Naumenko, T. I., Mikhailik, A. G., Muromtseva, L. H., & Guretskaya, Y. A. (2025). Vsesoyuznyj komitet po delam iskusstv pri Sovete narodnykh komissapov SSSR 1941–1945 [The All-Union Committee for the Affairs of the Arts under the Council of People’s Commissars of the USSR 1941–1945] (A. S. Ryzhinsky et al., Eds.). Istoricheskaya literatura. (In Russ.).
Bocharov, Yu. S., Saponov, M. A., Khrapchenko, V. M., & Khrapchenko, T. V. (2020). (Eds.). “Dorogaya Tamara Erastovna…”: Pamyati professora T. E. Tsytovich: Stranitsy zhizni i tvorchestva. Vospominaniya [“Dear Tamara Erastovna”: In Memory of Professor T. E. Tsytovich: Pages of Life and Work. Memories]. The Scholarly and Printing Center “Moscow Conservatory.” (In Russ.).
Naumenko, T. I. (2017). Working on the Soviet Opera after 1936. Contemporary Musicology, (4), 25–44. (In Russ.).
Naumenko, T. I. (2023). The “Song Opera” of the 1930s: In Search for New Poetics of the Genre. Problemy muzykal’noi nauki / Music Scholarship, (3), 58–67. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.56620/2782-3598.2023.3.058-067
Maksimenkov, L. V. (1997). Sumbur vmesto muzyki. Stalinskaya kul’turnaya revolyutsiya, 1936–1938 [Confusion Instead of Music: The Stalinist Cultural Revolution of 1936–1938]. Yuridicheskaya kniga. (In Russ.).
Solodovnikov, A. V. (1979). My byli molody togda. Vospominaniya [We Were Young Then. Memories]. In Yu. S. Rybakov, & M. D. Sedykh (Eds.), Teatral’nye stranitsy [Theatre Pages] (pp. 186–223). Iskusstvo. (In Russ.).
Balashov, N. I., & Karaulov, Yu. N. (2005). The Path of a Russian Philologist in the 20th Century: On the Centenary of the Birth of Academician M. B. Khrapchenko. Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 75(12), 1123–1131. (In Russ.).
Perkhin, V. V. (Ed.). (2007). Deyateli russkogo iskusstva i M. B. Khrapchenko, predsedatel’ Vsesoyuznogo komiteta po delam iskusstv: aprel’ 1939 – yanvar’ 1948: svod pisem [Russian Arts Affairs and the President of the All-Union Committee on Arts Affairs, April 1939 – January 1948, M. B. Khrapchenko: Collection of Letters]. Nauka. (In Russ.).
Kryukov, A. N. (2015). Muzyka i muzykanty voennogo Leningrada. Po vospominaniyam i dokumentam [Music and Musicians of Wartime Leningrad. Based on Memoirs and Documents]. Compozitor – Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russ.).
Dansker, O. L. (Ed.). (2000). Shostakovich v dnevnikakh M. O. Shtejnberga [Shostakovich in the Diaries of M. O. Steinberg]. In L. G. Kovnatskaya (Ed.), Shostakovich mezhdu mgnoveniem i vechnost’yu. Dokumenty, materialy, stat’i [Shostakovich between a Moment and Eternity. Documents, Materials, Articles] (pp. 83–148). Compozitor – Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russ.).
Glikman, I. D. (Ed.). (1993). Pis’ma k drugu: Pis’ma D. D. Shostakovicha k I. D. Glikmanu [Letters to a Friend: Letters from D. D. Shostakovich to I. D. Glikman]. DSCH – Compozitor – Sankt-Peterburg. (In Russ.).
Khentova, S. M. (1986). Dmitrij Shostakovich. Zhizn’ i tvorchestvo [Dmitry Shostakovich. Life and Work] (In 2 books, Book 2). Sovetskij kompozitor. (In Russ.).
Maximenkov, L. (2004). Stalin and Shostakovich: Letters to a “Friend”. In L. E. Fay (Ed.), Shostakovich and His World (pp. 43–58). Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9780691232195-006
Devyatov, S. V., Zhilyaev V. I., & Nevezhin, V. A. (2023). “‘The International’ is Outdated for Our People.” Creation of the National Anthem of the USSR (1943–1944). Rossijskaâ istoriâ, (3), 78–94. https://doi.org/10.31857/S2949124X23030082
Perkhin, V. V. (2019) “United by the Great Rus…”: From the History of the Genesis and Perception of the National Hymn (June 1943 – April 1944). Stephanos, 36(4), 38–67. Perkhin, V. (2019). https://doi.org/10.24249/2309-9917-2019-36-4-38-67
Nevezhin, V. A. (2011). Zastol’ya Iosifa Stalina. Kniga pervaya. Bol’shie kremlevskie priemy 1930-kh – 1940-kh gg. [Joseph Stalin’s Feasts. Book One. The Great Kremlin Receptions of the 1930s–1940s]. Novy Khronograf.
Sidorov, N., Topolyansky, V. (2007). Gimnokosmogoniya: dokumental’naya khronika voennogo vremeni [Gymnocosmogony: Documentary Chronicle of Wartime]. Kontinent [Continent], 134 (4), 236–290.
Volkov, S. M. (1979). Testimony. The Memories of Dmitri Shostakovich as related to and edited by Solomon Volkov. Limelight Editions.
Volkov, S. M. (2008). The Magical Chorus. A History of Russian Culture from Tolstoy to Solzhenitsyn. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group.
Balasanyan, K. S. (2005). K istorii ispolneniya kamernoj muzyki D. D. Shostakovicha (Po dnevnikam V. V. Borisovskogo) [On the History of Performance of Chamber Music by D. D. Shostakovich (Based on the Diaries of V. V. Borisovsky)]. In Dmitrij Shostakovich. Issledovaniya i materialy [Dmitri Shostakovich. Research and Materials] (Issue 1, pp. 45–66). DSCH. (In Russ.).
Elyanova, M. L. (2004). “Nepravdopodobnaya Pravda” [“The Implausible Truth”]. Music Academy, (2), 135–139. (In Russ.).
Dvoskina, E. M. (2008). Vos’maya simfoniya Shostakovicha i Stalinskaya premiya [Shostakovich’s Eighth Symphony and the Stalin Prize]. Music Academy, (2), 88–94. (In Russ.).
Svinyin, V. F., & Oseyev, K. A. (Eds.). (2007). Stalinskie premii. Dve storony odnoj medali [Stalin Prizes. Two Sides of the Same Medal]: Collection of Documentary and Artistic-Publicist Materials. Svinyin and Sons. (In Russ.).
Yakovlev, A. N., Nadzhafov, D. G., & Belousova, Z. S. (Eds.). (2005). Stalin i kosmopolitizm. 1945–1953. Dokumenty Agitpropa CK [Stalin and Cosmopolitanism. 1945–1953. Documents of the Agitation Propaganda of the Central Committee]. MFD: Materik. (In Russ.).
Vishnevetsky, I. G. (2009). Sergej Prokof’ev [Sergei Prokofiev]. Molodaya Gvardiya. (In Russ.).
DOI: https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2025-3-012-060
Copyright (c) 2025 Tatiana I. Naumenko
License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/