On the Structure of the 16th Century Madrigals on Texts in Fixed Poetic Forms
Abstract
Our study investigates madrigal settings of sestinas, sonnets and ballata with highly structured forms. They are, to a varying degree, unambiguously attributed to fixed poetic forms (formes fixes). In particular, the study explores the correspondence of the musical form to a specific fixed poetic form (rather than text-music correspondences of the most general nature, as is the case with the analysis of musico-poetic lines). A number of publications focusing on madrigal settings of texts in certain poetic forms (most often ballads) show that “the poetry precedes and influences the music” (Anthony Newcomb). This understanding is somewhat different from our observations, which have revealed two complementary descriptions. The first affirms the idea of precedence of the poetic form and its influence on the musical form; the key word for the second is “reformatting”: it describes the transformation of sestina stanzas, sonnets and ballata as they are set to music. Thus, we witness a certain tectonic shift:
• the displacement of boundaries of the poetic form,
• a change in the number of structural elements,
• the violation of original proportions,
• the replacement of the equality of poetic constructions with the equality of musical constructions, etc.
These and other similar signs of the refusal to simply follow the structure of the text are also the signs of a symmetrical metrotectonic construction produced exclusively by musical means. This occurs beyond the direct interaction of music with the word—in the sphere where the beauty of the numerical structure of the musical form becomes manifest (Georgi Conus, Alexey Losev).
Keywords: madrigal, fixed poetic form, musical form, symmetry, metrotectonism
For citation: Gerver L. L. On the Structure of the 16th Century Madrigals on Texts in Fixed Poetic Forms [Electronic source]. In: Sovremennye problemy muzykoznaniya / Contemporary Musicology, 2022, no. 2, pp. 4–47. (In Russ.) DOI: 10.56620/2587-9731-2022-2-004-047
References
Veselovskij A.N. Izbrannye stat’i [Selected articles]. Leningrad: Hudozhestvennaya literatura [Art Literature], 1939.
Gasparov M.L. Ocherk istorii evropejskogo stiha [An outline of the history of European verse]. M.: Nauka [Science], 1989.
Gasparov M.L. Tverdye formy [Fixed forms] [Elektronic resource]. In: Bol’shaya rossijskaya enciklopediya, 2005–2019. Available at: https://bigenc.ru/literature/text/4184552 (accessed: 21.02.2022).
Gerver L.L. Tverdaya poeticheskaya forma vs forma muzykal’naya: opyt analiza madrigalov na teksty sekstin [Fixed Poetic Form vs Musical Form: Experience of the Analysis of Madrigals on Sextina Texts]. In: Nauchnye shkoly v muzykovedenii XXI veka: k 125-letiyu uchebnyh zavedenij imeni Gnesinyh. Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj onlajn-konferencii 24–27 noyabrya 2020 goda [In: Scientific Schools in Musicology in the 21st Century: On the 125th Anniversary of the Gnesins’ Educational Institutions. roceedings of the International Scientific Online Conference, November 24–27, 2020]. Ed. by T.I. Naumenko. M.: Ros. akad. muzyki im. Gnesinyh [Gnesin Russian Academy of Music], 2020. Pp. 718–730.
Gerver L.L., Kovalevskaya D.A. Prisushche li metrotektonicheskoe sovershenstvo formy madrigalam Luki Marencio? [Is Metrotectonic Perfection Characteristic of Madrigals by Luca Marenzio]. In: Nauchnyj vestnik Moskovskoj konservatorii [Scientific Bulletin of the Moscow Conservatory]. 2019. № 4 (39). Pp. 44–69.
Girfanova M.E. Menzural’naya sistema kak istoricheskij tip zapadnoevropejskogo muzykal’nogo metra [The mensural system as a historical type of Western European musical metre]. Dr. sci. dis. 17.00.02. Kazan’, 2015.
Ignat’eva N.S. Madrigaly mantuanskih kompozitorov na teksty «Vernogo pastuha» Dzh. B. Gvarini (k istorii vtoroj praktiki) Madrigals by Mantuan composers to texts of J. B. Gvarini’s The Faithful Shepherd (to the history of the second practice)]. Candidate’s thesis. Moscow, 2017.
Konyus G.E. Nauchnoe obosnovanie muzykal’nogo sintaksisa (k izucheniyu voprosa) [Scientific rationale for musical syntax (to explore the question)]. Moscow: Gos. muz. izd-vo [State misic publishing house], 1935.
Losev A.F. Muzyka kak predmet logiki [Music as a Subject of Logic]. In: Losev A.F. Iz rannikh proizvedeniy [From the Early Works]. Moscow: Pravda [Truth], 1990.
Pankina E.V. Frottola v kul’ture ital’yanskogo Vozrozhdeniya: 1480–1530 [Frottola in Italian Renaissance culture: 1480–1530]. Doctor’s thesis. Moscow, 2018.
Panova L.G. Annenskij-petrarkist: “Dal’nie ruki” [Annensky Petrarchist: “Distant Hands”]. In: Dialog kul’tur: “Ital’yanskij tekst” v russkoj literature, “russkij tekst” v ital’yanskoj literature: Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferencii (IRYA RAN, 9–11 iyunya 2011 g.) [Dialogue of Cultures: “Italian Text” in Russian Literature, “Russian Text” in Italian Literature: Proceedings of an International Scientific Conference]. Ed. N.A. Fateeva. Moscow: Infotekh, 2013. P. 111–119.
Susidko I.P. Poeziya – sluzhanka muzyki? O roli poeticheskogo teksta v ital’yanskoj arii XVIII veka [Is poetry the servant of music? On the role of the poetic text in eighteenth-century Italian aria]. In: Nauchnye shkoly v muzykovedenii XXI veka: k 125-letiyu uchebnyh zavedenij imeni Gnesinyh. Materialy Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj onlajn-konferencii 24–27 noyabrya 2020 goda [In: Scientific Schools in Musicology in the 21st Century: On the 125th Anniversary of the Gnesins’ Educational Institutions. Proceedings of the International Scientific Online Conference, November 24–27, 2020]. Ed. by T.I. Naumenko. M.: Ros. akad. muzyki im. Gnesinyh [Gnesin Russian Academy of Music], 2020. Pp. 503–512.
Holopov Yu.N. Metricheskaya struktura perioda i pesennyh form [The Metrical Structure of Period and Song Forms]. In: Problemy muzykal’nogo ritma. Sbornik statey [Problems of Musical Rhythm. Collection of articles]. Ed. V.N. Holopova. Moscow: Muzyka [Music], 1978. P. 105–163.
Shor R. Ballada. Literaturnaya enciklopediya. V 11 t. [Ballada. Encyclopaedia of Literature. In 11 vols.]. [Мoscow], 1929–1939 [Elektronic resource]. In: Fundamental’naya elektronnaya biblioteka “Russkaya literatura i fol’klor” [Fundamental Digital Library “Russian Literature and Folklore”]. Available at: http://feb-feb.ru/feb/litenc/encyc (accessed: 26.02.2022).
Abramov-van Rijk E. The form of the monostrophic ballata as a frame for a logical demonstration. In: Plainsong and Medieval Music. Vol. 26. Iss. 1. Cambridge University Press, 2017. Р. 1–18.
D’Agostino G. On the Ballata Form(s) of Fifteenth-Century Italy: a Case of Historical Misunderstanding. In: “Et facciam dolçi canti”. Studi in onore di Agostino Ziino in occasione del suo 65° compleanno. LIM, 2003. Р. 295–330.
Einstein А. The Italian Madrigal. Ed. by R. Sessions, O. Strunk, A.Y. Krappe. In Three volumes. Vol. 2. Princeton Legacy Library edition, 2019.
Fallows D. Formes Fixes [Electronic edition]. In: The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians. London: Macmillan, 2001.
Harrán D. Verse Types in the Early Madrigal. In: Journal of the American Musicological Society, Vol. 22 (1969). Р. 27–53.
Newcomb A. The Ballata and the “Free” Madrigal in the Second Half of the Sixteenth Century. In: Journal of the American Musicological Society, Vol. 63, No. 3 (Fall 2010). Pp. 427–497.
O’Rourke R. Representation, Emotion, and the Madrigal in Sixteenth-Century Italy. Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the Executive Committee of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences. Columbia University, 2020.
[Petrarca F.]. Il Canzoniere di Francesco Petrarca. Edizione di riferimento: a cura di Giancarlo Contini, Einaudi, Torino 1964.
Schick H. Musikalische Einheit im Madrigal von Rore bis Monteverdi: Phänomene, Formen und Entwicklungslinien. Tutzing: Verlegt bei Hans Schneider, 1998.
Schubert P., Cumming J.E. Text and Motif c. 1500: A New Approach to Text Underlay. In: Early Music. Vol. 40, No. 1. 2012. P. 3–13.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2022-2-004-047
Copyright (c) 2022 Larisa L. Gerver
License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/