Music Theory à la Leningrad: an Interview with Tatiana Bershadskaya

Philip Ewell

Abstract


For over sixty years Tatiana Bershadskaya has played a central role in music and music theory in Russia. Specifically, she is the undisputed leader of the so-called “Leningrad School” of music theory, which arose in contradistinction to the strong influence of Moscow, and what is often called the “Moscow School,” in the twentieth century. For much of the twentieth century there was a certain tension between these two schools, with the more- famous Moscow School often outshining its northern counterpart.
The Leningrad School traces its roots back to Boleslav Yavorsky, who worked primarily in and around Moscow, and had little to do with St. Petersburg. Yet both schools owe their existence, for the most part, to developments that took place in nineteenth-century St. Petersburg. Beginning with Rimsky-Korsakov, there was a strong pull toward harmonic functionalism in the works of Russian music theorists. This culminated in the works of Gregori Catoire, Igor Sposobin, and others, who essentially founded the “Moscow School” of music theory in Russia in the 1920s and 1930s. Bershadskaya represents another Russian music-theoretical tradition, which stemmed from the work of Yavorsky and, subsequently, Boris Asafiev, Christopher Kushnarev, and Yuri Tiulin, the latter two with whom she studied. In this work, in an introductory essay, the author contextualizes these two schools of music theory, and the role that Bershadskaya and her predecessors played in their formation. After the introductory essay the author offers an extensive interview that he conducted with Bershadskaya at her apartment invSt. Petersburg, from February 15, 2018, in which she discusses her life in and her views on music and music theory.

Keywords: Music theory, Moscow school, Leningrad school, Tatiana Bershadskaya, Hugo Riemann, Grigori Catoire, Boleslav Yavorsky, Yuri Tiulin, Yuri Kholopov

For citation: Ewell P. Theory à la Leningrad:  an Interview with Tatiana Bershadskaya [Electronic source]. In: Sovremennye problemy muzykoznaniya / Contemporary Musicology, 2019, no. 4, pp. 121–164. DOI: 10.56620/2587-9731-2019-4-121-164


Full Text:

PDF Abstract

References


Aranovsky M.G. Teoreticheskaya koncepciya B.L. YAvorskogo [The theoretical conception of Boleslav Yavorsky] [Electronic resource] // Iskusstvo muzyki: teoriya i istoriya [The art of music: Theory and history]. 2012. № 6. P. 41–60. URl: https://hra.sias.ru/upload/iblock/a64/aranovskii.pdf

Asafiev B.V. Muzykal'naya forma kak process [Musical form as process]. Second edition. 2 vols. Vol. 2. В 2 ч. Ч. 2. Leningrad: Muzyka [Music], 1971.

Bershadskaya Т.S. V ladah s garmoniej, v garmonii s ladami: ocherki [In modes with harmony, in harmony with modes: Essays]. St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg Conservatory, 2011.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Garmoniya kak element muzykal'noj sistemy [Harmony as an element of a musical system]. St. Petersburg: UT, 1997.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Kurs analiza muzykal'nyh proizvedenij: Programma dlya muzykal'nyh uchilishch [Course in the analysis of musical compositions: A program for specialized music schools]. Leningrad: Muzyka [Music], 1951.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Lekcii po garmonii [Lectures in harmony]. St. Petersburg: Kompozitor [Composer], 2003.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Leningradskaya–peterburgskaya shkola teorii muzyki [The Leningrad-St. Petersburg school of music theory] // Sankt-Peterburgskaya konservatoriya v mirovom muzykal'nom prostranstve [St. Petersburg conservatory in a world-wide musical context] / ed. by N.I. Degtiareva. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Politekhnicheskogo Instituta, 2013. P. 9–15.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Netradicionnye formy pis'mennyh rabot po garmonii v konservatoriyah [Non-traditional forms of written harmony work in conservatories]. Second edition. St. Petersburg: Kompozitor [Composer], 2001.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Osnovnye kompozicionnye zakonomernosti mnogogolosiya russkoj narodnoj krest'yanskoj pesni [Fundamental compositional rules in multi-voiced Russian folk-peasant songs]. Leningrad: Muzgiz [Music Publisher], 1961.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Stat'i raznyh let [Articles from various years]. St. Petersburg: Soiuz Khudozhnikov [Union of Artist], 2004.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Funkcii garmonii v muzykal'noj sisteme [Functional harmony in a musical system]. Leningrad: LOLGK [Leningrad Order of Lenin State Conservatory], 1989.

Bershadskaya Т.S. Maslenkova L.M., Nezvanov B.A. et al. Kurs teorii muzyki [Course in music theory]. Leningrad: Muzyka, 1988.

Dmitrij SHostakovich: v pis'mah i dokumentah [Dmitri Shostakovich: In letter and documents] / ed. by I.A. Bobykina. Moscow: М.: Gosudarstvennyj central'nyj muzej muzykal'noj kul'tury im. M.I. Glinki [State Central Museum of Musical Culture named after M.I. Glinka], Reklamnoizdatel'skaya firma «Antikva» [Advertising and publishing company “Antikva”], 2000.

Dubovsky J.I., Evseev S.V., Methodin I.V., Sokolov V.V. Uchebnik garmonii [Harmony textbook]: 2 vols. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo “Iskusstvo” [State Publishing House “Art”], 1939.

Catoire G.L. Teoreticheskij kurs garmonii [Theoretical course of harmony]. 2 Vols. Vol. 1. Moscow: Gosmuzizdat [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1924–1925.

Konferenciya po teorii ladovogo ritma [Conference on the theory of modal rhythm] // Proletarskij muzykant [Proletarian musician]. 1930. № 2. P. 6–9.

Kushnarev Ch.S. Voprosy istorii i teorii armyanskoj monodicheskoj muzyki [Questions on the history and theory of Armenian monodic music]. Leningrad: Gosmuzizdat [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1958.

Kushnarev Ch.S. O polifonii: Sb. Statej [On polyphony, collected articles]. Moscow: Muzyka [Music], 1971.

Lunacharsky A.V. Neskol'ko zamechanij o teorii ladovogo ritma [Several observations on the theory of modal rhythm] // Proletarskij muzykant [Proletarian musician]. 1930. № 2. P. 10–13.

Protopopov S.V. Elementy stroeniya muzykal'noj rechi. 2 vols. Vol.1 / ed. by B. Yavorsky. Moscow: Gosmuzizdat [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1930.

Rimsky-Korsakov N.A. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij: Literaturnye proizvedeniya i perepiska [Complete collected works: Literary works and cor- respondence]. Vol. 4. Uchebnik garmonii [Harmony textbook]. Moscow: Muzgiz [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1960.

Rimsky-Korsakov N.A. Uchebnik garmonii [Harmony textbook]. Lithograph printing. St. Petersburg, 1885.

Ryzhkin J.Ja. Novoe izdanie uchebnika garmonii [New edition of the harmony textbook] // Sovetskaya muzyka [Soviet music]. 1950. № 2.

Tiulin Yu.N. Iskusstvo kontrapunkta [The art of counterpoint]. Moscow: Muzyka [Music], 1968.

Tiulin Yu.N. Natural'nye i al'teracionnye lady [Natural and alternating modes]. Moscow: Muzyka [Music], 1971.

Tiulin Yu.N. Stroenie muzykal'noj rechi [The structure of musical speech]. Leningrad: Muzgiz [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1969.

Tiulin Yu.N. Uchenie o garmonii [Studies in harmony]. Third edition. Moscow: Muzyka [Music], 1966.

Tiulin Yu.N., Privano N.G. Teoreticheskie osnovy garmonii [ The theoretical bases of harmony]. Leningrad: Muzgiz [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1965.

Tiulin Yu.N., Privano N.G. Uchebnik garmonii [Harmony textbook]. 2 vols. Moscow: Muzgiz [State Publishing House Music Sector], 1964.

Kholopov Yu.N. Garmoniya: prakticheskij kurs [(Harmony: A practical course]. 2 vols. Moscow: Kompozitor [Composer], 2003.

Kholopov Yu.N. Garmoniya: teoreticheskij kurs [Harmony: a theoretical course]. Moscow: Lan’ [Doe], 2003.

Kholopov Yu.N., Kirillina L.V., Kyuregyan T.S., Lyzhov G.I., Pospelova R.L., Tsenova V.S. Muzykal'no-teoreticheskie sistemy [Music-theoretical systems]. Moscow: Kompozitor [Composer], 2006.

Yavorsky B.L. Izbrannoe: pis'ma, vospominaniya [Favorites: Letters, recollections]. Moscow: Kompozitor [Composer], 2008.

Yavorsky B.L. Stat'i, vospominaniya, perepiska [Articles, remembrances, correspondence] / ed. by I. Rabinovich and D. Shostakovich. Moscow: Sovetskiĭ Kompozitor [Soviet composer], 1972.

Yavorsky B.L. Stroenie muzykal'noj rechi. Materialy i zametki [The structure of musical speech. Materials and notes]. Moscow, 1908.

Carpenter E. The Theory of Music in Russia and the Soviet Union, ca. 1650–1950. PhD diss., University of Pennsylvania, 1988.

Ewell P. Conference Report: Inaugural Meeting of the Russian Society for Music Theory (OTM) [Electronic resource] // Music Theory Online. 2013. № 19 (4). URL: https://mtosmt.org/issues/mto.13.19.4/mto.13.19.4.ewell.html

Ewell P. Rethinking Octatonicism: Views from Stravinsky’s Homeland [Electronic resource] // Music Theory Online. 2012. № 18 (4). URL: https://mtosmt.org/issues/mto.12.18.4/mto.12.18.4.ewell.html

Jackson L. Modulation and Tonal Space in the Practical Manual Of Harmony: Rimsky-Korsakov’s Harmonic Theory and Its Historical Antecedents. PhD diss., Columbia University, 1996.

Lupishko M. Konyus’ ‘Metrotechtonism’ and Yavorsky’s ‘Modal Rhythm’: Parallels Between Music and Architecture in Early Soviet Music Theory // Music and Figurative Arts in the Twentieth Century / ed. by R. Illiano. Turnhout: Brepols, 2016. P. 73–94

McQuere G. The Theories of Boleslav Yavorsky // Russian Theoretical Thought in Music / ed. by G. McQuere. Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press. Repr. Rochester: University of Rochester Press, (1983) 2009. P. 109– 164.

Sabaneev L. Modern Russian Composers / trans. by J.A. Joffe. New York: International Publishers, 1927.

Tull J. B.V. Asafiev’s “Music Form as a Process”: Translation and Commentary. PhD diss. Ohio State University, 1977.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2019-4-121-164

Copyright (c) 2019 Philip Ewell

License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/