La finta giardiniera by Pasquale and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Versions of Two Opera Capitals (Rome and Munich)
Abstract
The article considers issues that arise when comparing Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s opera La finta giardiniera (Munich, 1775) and the opera of the same name by Pasquale Anfossi (Rome, 1774), which appeared a year before Mozart’s. This kind of comparison, which is a traditional subject for Mozart studies, has been undertaken repeatedly. However, almost 40 years have passed since the publication of Volker Mattern’s most extensive study on this topic (1989). During this time, views on the musical context of the 1770s, as well as ideas about the specifics of the operatic genres of that era and the norms of their poetics, have changed noticeably. The article re-formulates the features of the sentimentalist variety of opera buffa, clarifies the extent to which the anonymous libretto La finta giardiniera corresponds to them, and, using the example of a comparison of the music of several key numbers, demonstrates the extent to which Anfossi and Mozart followed the genre canon or the dramatic innovations proposed by the librettist. As a result, Mattern’s main conclusion about the “individual style” that first clearly manifested itself in this Mozart opera is supplemented by significant comments and subject to critical revision.
Keywords: La finta giardiniera, Pasquale Anfossi, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Niccolò Piccinni, Carlo Goldoni, Italian opera buffa, sentimentalism, poetics of opera libretto
For citation: Lutsker, P. V. (2025). La finta giardiniera by Pasquale Anfossi and Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart: Versions of Two Opera Capitals (Rome and Munich). Contemporary Musicology, 9(4), 49―81. https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2025-4-049-081References
Abert, H. (1922). W. A. Mozart. Breitkopf & Haertel.
Einstein, A. (trans. A. Mendel, & N. Broder). (1962). Mozart, His Character, His Work. Oxford University Press.
Mattern, V. (1989). Das Dramma giocoso „La finta Giardiniera“. Ein Vergleich der Vertonnungen von Pasquale Anfossi und Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Laaber-Verlag.
Yordanova, I., & Camões, J. (Eds.). (2022). Eighteenth-Century Theatre Capitals: From Lisbon to St. Petersburg. Hollitzer Verlag. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv2phprbg
Kunze, S. (1984). Mozarts Opern. Reclam.
Angermüller, R. (1978). Wer war der Librettist von „La finta Giardiniera“. In Mozart-Jahrbuch 1976/77 (pp. 1–8). Barenreiter.
Lutsker, P. V., & Susidko, I. P. (2015). Mozart i ego vremya [Mozart and His Time]. Classica 21. (In Russ.).
Rista, P. (2018). At the Origins of Classical Opera: Carlo Goldoni and the “dramma giocoso per musica.” Peter Lang Verlag. https://doi.org/10.3726/b14367
Lutsker, P. (2014). Gomer, Addison, Gol’doni — o syuzhetnykh istokakh libretto “Graf Karamella” [Homer, Addison, Goldoni: On the Plot Sources of the Libretto Il conte Caramella]. Problems of the theatre/Proscaenium, XVI(3–4), 231–243. (In Russ.). https://theatre.sias.ru/upload/voprosy_teatra/vop_3-4.2014.pdf
Lutsker (Luzker), P. (2013). From Pamela to La Buona Figliuola or How a Heroine of Fashionable Novel Found Herself on the Opera Stage. Starinnaya Muzyka (Early music quarterly), (1), 8–15. (In Russ.). https://stmus.ru/Archive%20files/starmus-2013-1.pdf
DOI: https://doi.org/10.56620/2587-9731-2025-4-049-081
Copyright (c) 2025 Pavel V. Lutsker
License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/